Fire Damage Arizona watersheds

Share:
Wildfires on Arizona's brush-covered mountains cause severe, long-lasting damage by destroying protective vegetation, accelerating soil erosion, and triggering destructive floods. The 1934 Saddle Mountain fire illustrates these devastating impacts, where the loss of plant cover led to unprecedented runoff that caused extensive downstream property damage, including to a local mercury mine. These events underscore the critical importance of watershed protection to prevent costly environmental and economic disasters.

Featured in the December 1937 Issue of Arizona Highways

McNary lumber mill, one of the largest and most modern mills in the Southwest, located at McNary in the White Mountains.
McNary lumber mill, one of the largest and most modern mills in the Southwest, located at McNary in the White Mountains.
BY: Elbert L. Little, Jr.

Fires Damage Arizona

By ELBERT L. LITTLE, JR.

FIRES on the brush-covered mountains of central Arizona are destructive in many ways, according to studies being made by the U. S. Forest Service. In addition to burning of timber, forage, and other plant cover, fires have more serious and lasting effects in the removal of soil and in the damage caused by the floods which follow. On the valuable watersheds of Arizona above large reservoirs, increased soil erosion by fire and other causes results in greater deposits of silt in these reservoirs.

Investigation of one large area burned in July, 1934, shows that damaging influences of the fire are still being felt in 1937, after three years. This fire, the one on Saddle Mountain, occured on the Tonto National Forest about 50 miles northeast of Phoenix in an inaccessible, rugged portion of Mazatzal Mountains 4,500 to 6,500 feet above sea level. A total of 7½ square miles of mountainous watershed at the head of Sycamore Creek, a tributary of the Verde River, was devastated.

As this remote area was not then covered by lookout towers and as visibility was obscured by smoke from other fires, this fire, probably set by lightning, was not discovered until it had gained considerable headway. Facilities for the detection of fires in the Mazatzal Mountains have been improved this year by the construction of a new lookout tower on Mount Ord.

When the Saddle Mountain fire was detected, available men of this sparsely settled area were away fighting other fires. However, 150 men, including Civilian Conservation Corps enrollees from Tonto National Forest camps, were recruited from points 25 to 50 miles distant.

The fire fighters found nature against them. The summer of 1934 was one of the driest on record, and lack of rain caused the vegetation to be parched and easily burned. Temperature was soaring above 100 degrees daily, humidity was very low, and winds were strong. The rough mountains had very few trails and were covered with dense brush 4 to 7 feet high which was almost impenetrable. Horses or pack animals were not available, hence food and water had to be packed to the fire line by men on foot.

Brush and timber were so inflammable that the flames became a crown fire at times as high as 100 feet, jumping over control lines and endangering the lives of the fire fighters. Smoke from the fire was visible at Phoenix and other valley towns miles away.

Against all these odds, the men by working day and night had the fire under control 2½ days after it was discovered. Cost of extinguishing this large fire, including labor, supplies, and transportation, totaled more than $5,000.

Compared with the far-reaching effects of the fire, the actual costs of putting out the Saddle Mountain fire was small. This fire destroyed all trees, shrubs, grasses, and weeds in its path and left only a mass of ashes and blackened skeletons of charred trees and shrubs. Three hundred acres of mature timber, mostly Arizona cypresses and ponderosa pines with some pinon and junipers, were burned.

Vegetation on the remaining area, about seven square miles, consisted originally of brush or chaparral of scrub live oaks, manzanitas, mountain-mahoganies, sugar sumacs, buckthorns, silktassels, and other evergreen shrubs. Brush area of this type furnishes forage for cattle and sheep and serves to control erosion and regulate the flow of streams.

Watersheds . . .

The burned area is being observed by the Parker Creek Branch of the Southwestern Forest and Range Experiment Station, which was established by the U. S. Forest Service in 1931 to conduct erosion and streamflow investigation on the Salt River watershed. From the examinations made to date it is estimated that it will be many years before the vegetation completely recovers from the damage of this fire.

Most of the brush, although killed to the ground, survived through deep roots. When the delayed summer rains of 1934 finally started the last of July, these roots sent up numerous sprouts. By the fall of 1934 these sprouts averaged one foot in height and in 1935 they grew another foot. In the spring of 1937 they averaged 3 to 4 feet high. The burned area is still easily recognizable by the smaller sprouts and older dead limbs.

Gregg hornbushes, which are important browse plants, and manzanitas are unable to produce sprouts, and hence were entirely destroyed by the fire. Grasses, which are more valuable than shrubs as forage and in preventing soil erosion, were killed. Because of the difficulty of reseeding after the topsoil is washed away, grasses recover from fire slowly. Thus both forage and protective watershed cover are reduced by fires.

In places the heat from the flames was so intense that rocks were charred and shattered, and duff and roots of herbaceous vegetation were completely consumed. However, where the brush cover was not so thick and the fire not so severe, grasses survived. A few annual weeds of slight value for forage and cover, called firewood because they follow burns, were also present after the fire.

Chaparral, or brush vegetation, has high value for watershed protection in controlling soil erosion and floods. In southern California, where similar hillsides are covered by chaparral vegetation, high losses in property and even lives are caused by floods on burned watersheds.

Fires Damage Arizona Watersheds

Due to burning of vegetation, soil and rocks are washed away to fill reservoirs and devastate property below. Water needed for irrigation and domestic use is wasted in flood waters which break through dams, destroy buildings, and take their toll in human lives.

The Saddle Mountain fire was followed by similar effects during the first summer rains the last of July 1934. Burning removed the plant cover, which cover ordinarily checked the fall of rain and helped the rain water to soak into the ground. A normal summer rain falling on this desolate, fire-swept watershed was sufficient to cause higher run-off and floods than has ever been known.

Soil which had required centuries for its formation (from rock and decaying plant material) was removed in a single storm. A layer of soil from 1 to 3 inches deep was washed from the surface of steep hillsides, leaving the surface covered with a bare rocky pavement. Gravel and rocks were piled against the bases of dead shrubs along the slopes. Gutters 1 to 2 feet deep and 3 to 5 feet wide were carved out of the soil and loose rock of the steeper slopes by the first storm, and were enlarged still more by later rains.

With no cover of plants and no soil left to absorb the rain water, the water rushed down in torrents, carrying rocks and mud and filling the narrow mountain valleys with floods of great height. Even normally dry channels were filled with water to a depth of 8 feet. Silt and debris were carried on to lower levels and deposited in broader valleys.

Flood waters from a small drainage on the burned watershed cut down through a mine tunnel of a mercury, or quicksilver mine at the edge of the burned area, and caused damage totaling about $30,000. The shaft for several hundred feet was filled almost to the roof with mud, and water.

Consequently, the mine was unable to resume operations, hence expensive equipment remained idle and men were left unemployed. The raging stream undermined tracks and buildings and washed away about a hundred yards of road to the mine. It filled and destroyed a dam where spring water had been developed. Storm water with its load of erosion products disconnected the pipe line and bent and twisted joints of 2-inch iron pipe.

Farther down the channel the flood carried away a five-room frame house, destroyed an engine, filled a truck with debris and wrecked it, and washed out a bridge. Water stood as high as 18 inches in other mine buildings above the banks of the usually dry canyon bed.

High waters of this depth had never before been experienced at this mine. Other floods occurred on this burned watershed in the summer of 1935 and 1936 and winter of 1937, but these were smaller and much less destructive. More floods may be expected after heavy rains until the vegetation heals over the burned watershed.

Thus all miners, prospectors, ranchers, homesteaders, and vacationists should be mindful of the value of watershed protection and the injurious effect of fire in these brush-covered mountains. All who have experienced the disastrous consequences of fire are convinced of the importance of maintaining a protective plant cover.

The slogan, "Everybody loses when timber burns," could well be amended to include the brush-covered mountains of Arizona. Here fires have almost permanent effects in the destruction of forage and timber, removal of soils, erosion of hillsides, production of floods with damage to property, and filling of reservoirs with silt.