THE YUCCA AND THE MOTH
the YUCCA and the MOTH
One of Nature's Most Enduring And Endearing Love Affairs Part One By JOSEPH WOOD KRUTCH Part Two By MRS. ANDREE ROBINSON
Remarkable — Uncommon and Extraordinary are synonymous with this article and the people who presented it for us.
Joseph Wood Krutch is the remarkable man of letters whose story of the “Moth and the Candle,” inspired a remarkable woman to dedicate five years to the fulfillment of a most extraordinary photographic accomplishment, in documenting one of nature’s most uncommon cycles of life perpetuation.
Dr. Krutch, who now resides in Tucson, Arizona, is a world renowned and much honored author, professor, critic, philosopher and naturalist, familiar to ARIZONA HIGHWAYS readers as the editor of Great American Nature Writings, and whose writing has appeared in these pages.
It is with grateful acknowledgement to his publishers that we present in part, chapter six, “The Moth and the Candle” from his book, “The Voice of the Desert.”
THE MOTH WHO SINGES HIS WINGS HAS POINTED MANY A moral but he does not “desire” the flame, not even in the dim way that the first scorpion to leave the water may have “desired” to succeed in his dangerous adventure. The moth accomplishes no purpose of its own and none appropriate to nature at large. He is merely the victim of a situation which can seldom have arisen before man put in his appearance long after moths and many other insects had developed a tropism which was usually harmless during millions of years.
A moth’s wings beat faster when light falls upon his eyes, and when it falls more strongly on one eye than on the other, the wings on one side beat faster than those on the other. Irresistibly his flight curves toward the source and if he reaches it, he dies — a victim of one of the mistakes which nature sometimes makes because even she cannot foresee every eventuality.
But in the case of a certain moth which lives in the desert and of a certain candle which grows there the situation is different.
Almost anywhere in the Southwest you will find as a conspicuous feature of the landscape one or another of the yuccas with their large bundle of stiff, sword-sharp leaves and, in early summer, an incredibly tall spire of innumerable creamy white blossoms held high on a great spike which shot up suddenly from the middle of the sword cluster. Pass by again in the fall and the spire will be bearing handsome pods which split open as they dry and scatter innumerable shiny black seeds on the sand. Though a bit difficult to gather, the pods make a fine addition to a winter bouquet and those who gather them often notice that each is perforated by at least one hole from which some insect has obviously emerged.
Sometimes the collector will search for a “perfect” specimen but perfect ones are not to be found. The “infestation” was necessary. Either the ovary from which the pod developed was “infested” or it didn’t mature. Thereby hangs a tale as strange as any the desert has to tell and in certain important respects the most difficult to explain of all the strange tales which are told of the interdependence of insects and flowers. The hole was made by the larva of a moth, and just to make the question we are about to ask as neat as possible, it happens that certain species of yucca are still commonly called by the name which the Spaniards gave them: Our Lord’s Candle.
Does Pronuba yuccasella, the moth in question, “desire” this particular candle? Please wait until you have heard the whole story before you answer.
Everybody — or at least everybody old enough to have been a child before directer methods of sex instruction came into fashion — knows about the bees and the flowers. If he did not lose all interest in the subject as he began to realize its remoter personal implications, he probably now knows at least in a very general way that many plants depend upon many insects and some, even, upon certain birds, to help them in what the eighteenth century liked to call “their nuptial rites.” Orchard growers tend bees principally to increase their yield of apples and plums and pears; Darwin wrote a classic on the pollination of orchids; the Smyrna fig would not fruit in California until the particular wasp which acts as marriage broker for it in the Near East was imported to perform his function here, etc. etc.
But in every known case except that of the moth and the candle it is a somewhat one-sided affair with all the “intention” being on the part of the flower. Though the insect may be lured by a scent which it likes — even by the stench of rotten meat in the case of certain tropical blossoms polinated by flesh-eating flies — and though he may be rewarded with nectar or with edible pollen, he does not do anything directly calculated to fertilize the flower. Sometimes the flower is so constructed that, for instance, the insect cannot get at the nectar without brushing against the pollen-bearing anthers and then against a stigma which will ultimately conduct the gene-bearing protoplasm of the pollen down to the ovules below. But he does not deliberately fertilize the plant and it would not affect his chances of passing on the torch to his posterity if the flower were not fertilized. The plant uses the insect but there is no active cooperation on the insect's part.
Consider, on the other hand, what happens in the unique case of the yucca and its attendant moth. In the first place, though there are many species of yuccas, only a single one of them — and it does not grow in this region — appears to be capable of getting along without the moth upon which all the rest depend. Moreover the moths, in their turn, are no less completely dependent upon the yuccas because their larva cannot feed upon anything except its maturing seeds. But this situation, which is odd without being unique, is not all. What is unique is the fact that the moth goes through a series of purposeful actions which have no other function except to fertilize a flower which could not be fertilized in any other way. If we naïvely interpreted its actions, we should find ourselves compelled to say it "knows what it is doing."
The classic observation was made seventy-five years ago by the remarkable Missouri entomologist, Charles V. Riley, though the subject has been much studied and written about since Riley himself fully described the crucial, incredible event as he observed it on a cultivated species grown in the neighborhood of St. Louis. Several different insects frequent the flowers to eat the nectar or the pollen but perform no service in return. Meanwhile the female of the indispensable moth rests quietly in the half-closed blossoms.
When evening comes she goes in turn to several of the flowers just opening for their one night of perfect bloom. While the male, who has already done his duty, flutters uselessly about, she collects from the anthers a ball of the pollen which is surrounded by a sticky gum to prevent its accidental dispersal. After she has collected under her chin a mass somewhat larger than her head, she climbs the pistil of a different flower and into it she inserts her egg tube about a third of the way down from the top and injects several eggs. However she "knows" that if she left it at that her larva would have nothing to feed on.
Accordingly, she mounts the rest of the way up the pistil, deposits the pollen ball on the stigma, and moves her head back and forth to rub the pollen well in. She eats neither nectar nor pollen. She gets no immediate benefit from her action. It has no purpose other than to fertilize the flower.
The insect which does these remarkable things is nothing much to look at — a little inch-long moth, silvery white in color and, so far as anyone knows, quite conventional in behavior except during the one great moment when it is impelled to act as though it knew a great deal about the physiology of plants as well as about the life history of its own species.
Most of what happens after the fertilization of the flower follows a familiar pattern. The flowers wither and a few days later the wormlike larva can be found. In time it will bore its way out of the maturing pod, drop to the ground, spin a cocoon a few inches below the surface, and there transform itself into an adult completely equipped to repeat, next year, the whole complicated process. Since there are commonly not more than two larvae per pod, they eat only a few of the perhaps two hundred seeds which the pod produces. From the standpoint of the yucca it is a very good arrangement since the sacrifice of a few seeds is a small price to pay for a very efficient job of fertilization. The staggering question for anyone who has committed himself to "explaining" nature is simply this: How on earth was such a system of mutual cooperation for individual ends ever worked out?
Evidently the yucca and the yucca moth came to their mutual understanding a long time ago — certainly before the plant genus had evolved the many species now flourishing — because, with one exception previously mentioned, they all seem to be signatories to the agreement; certainly, also, long enough ago for the Pronuba moth to have itself evolved into at least several distinguishable species, because those which visit certain yuccas are slightly different from those which visit others. On the other hand, moth and yucca have not always worked together, because the flower continues to secrete a nectar which now merely attracts useless insects of various sorts and presumably it learned to do that at a time before Pronuba got into the habit of paying a visit on business of her own for which no honeyed inducement is necessary.
Apparently, sometime during the millennia when the two were engaged in a late phase of their evolution and separating themselves into the different species of moth and yucca, they must have themselves have kept together. "Wherever thou goest I go," said the moth, because, again with the one single exception, where a yucca is native, so is a Pronuba. Attempt to grow the former outside its range and it may flower very nicely. But "no moth, no seed" seems to be the absolute rule.
The Mr. Riley who first told the world about Pronuba was a distinguished entomologist. He had the confidence of his professional brethren and textbook after textbook has repeated his tale. But is it just possible that he was overenthusiastic? How many other people have watched the performance and can vouch for it from their own experience?
Well, I confess that the shadow of such doubts crossed my own mind. Of the various references to Pronuba with which I was familiar, only one after Riley’s own seemed on internal evidence to be indubitably first hand. The most learned entomologist of this region where yucca flourishes confessed that he had never seen the performance and didn’t know anybody who had. Not too willingly — since I knew the difficulties, which include, besides the dilatoriness of the insect, darkness, a limited blooming season, and flowers lifted high above one’s head — I decided to try to see for myself. And to sustain any suspense which any reader may feel, I did. Three times Pronuba demonstrated before my eyes how she performed the crucial act, mounting the pistil of the recently opened flower and with prolonged purposefulness rubbing the pistil vigorously to get the pollen well in.
Partly to avoid the possibility that some amateur alienist might telephone a mental hospital that for several evenings a maniac had been seen standing for two hours and more peering at yucca flowers with a flashlight, I decided to make my observations well out into the desert and some twenty miles from town. And for poetic if not for strictly scientific reasons it was a good idea. It is one thing to read about what Pronuba does. It would be quite another to see her at work in a neighbor’s back yard. But the performance belongs properly among the mysteries which one can only appreciate fully when the context is remote from the human and as exclusively as possible in that of almost timeless nature.
The moonless night was brilliant with stars. In the distance a coyote pack obligingly set up its chorus which is as wild a sound as one is likely to hear anywhere. And then, presently, there was Pronuba, even more insignificant looking than I had expected her to be, performing her delicate operation precisely, no doubt, as her ancestors had performed it millions of times during millions of springs. On the horizon the lights of town were just visible. In all that town few knew about, perhaps none had ever seen, the strange actions of this silent moth without whom the tall spires of flowers would never conceive their seeds and without whom, therefore, the whole race of yuccas would gradually die out. It was for the almost invisible moth, not for you or me or any aesthetically appreciative human spectator, that the great masses of flowers were lifted high.
Part Two — THE PHOTOGRAPHIC TRUTH
Our remarkable lady, Mrs. Andree Robinson, was born seventy years ago in Saigon, then French Indo-China. Her father, Emile Roux, a career officer in the Army of France, sent Andree to Paris for her formal education. However, his varied military assignments afforded Andree a world-wide background with much of it on the African continent.
In 1921 she married Dr. Howard Robinson, a physician in the Canadian Army. Later the Robinsons came to Arizona where he practiced in Globe, Miami and Tucson, including several years as a physician with the Miami-Inspiration Hospital.
Andree purchased her first camera in 1948 so she could photograph the wonders of nature which always fascinated her. That she became an accomplished photographer was evident at the more than eighty international salons where her prints were chosen for exhibition.
After Dr. Robinson’s death, a little more than five years ago, Andree’s pattern of life was set after she read Joseph Wood Krutch’s story of “The Moth and the Candle.” She determined not only to witness the phenomenon but also to record it on film in color. We are proud to present several chosen photographs from the many frames that were necessary to record this marvel of nature. From this point we quote Mrs. Robinson:
It was my good fortune for several years to live in Globe, Arizona, county seat of Gila County in the heart of the Apache country. The area is surrounded by hills and canyons where many yuccas grow. I learned that this beautiful plant could not exist were it not for the aid of a small white silvery moth. The moth is totally dependent on the yucca to hatch, protect and feed her larvae.
At the Public Library I read all I could about yuccas and about the Pronuba moth. I read Dr. Krutch’s wonderful story several times over and the idea of photographing this amazing marvel came to me.
I did not realize at first how difficult my project was going to be and for how long it would keep me occupied. One evening in May, accompanied by my grandchildren, Judy and Jim, I started down the canyon looking for a good Yucca Elata. We did not have to go very far before we found a beautiful specimen. Keen eyed Judy soon spied the little moth on a sharp, green leaf of the yucca but it quickly zigzagged away and we lost it. The wing tips of the pronuba are white but underneath they are dark brown. It makes it hard to see. Then Jim suggested we open a blossom. We found the little moth at the base of one of the stamens. Soon the light began to fade and it became too dark for us to continue our studies but we were all happy with our first night’s discovery. Back home I turned back to the task of learning how to photograph the complicated activities of the insect. The yucca blossoms open at night and the moth is nocturnal which made it necessary for me to use a large red flashlight to be able to see after dark. After many trials and errors, I found a good exposure scale for daylight Agfachrome film with my electronic flash. The rest required five years’ time and a great deal of patience.
First I had to find the moths in the many stages of their involvements. In five years I witnessed the mating only once and that by sheer luck. Each phase of the egg laying and pollination is accomplished so quickly that one loses the action.
Already a member? Login ».