Flagstaff at 100

Share:
Celebrating the 100th year of its incorporation, the mountain community of 50,000 looks to the future while taking pride in its humble beginning.

Featured in the May 1994 Issue of Arizona Highways

BY: Rose Houk

“Twenty-five of our prominent men including members of the council, county officials, bankers, and professors were charged with violation of section one of the ordinance number 22, for riding a bicycle upon the sidewalks within the town of Flagstaff. The fine in each case was $2.50.”

Thus reported George Hochderffer, town marshal of Flagstaff in the year 1895. Bicycles had captured the imaginations of many of Flagstaff’s upstanding citizens, and apprehending disobedient cyclists was one of Marshal Hochderffer’s first acts for the newly incorporated town.

This year Flagstaff is having a birthday to celebrate the 100th anniversary of its incorporation. It’s a young town, so young that author and historian emeritus Platt Cline still remembers George Hochderffer. “I was at his 90th birthday,” Cline told me as we sat in his book-lined study one afternoon. In fact, he and Hochderffer shared the same birthday, “and we were both left-handed,” laughed Cline.

In many ways, George Hochderffer would still feel right at home in Flagstaff, especially downtown. He would see the Babbitt Building restored to its original 1888 condition; the Bank Hotel, whose interior was of brick that George likely helped make; Judge John Weatherford’s hotel a block away; the old post office; P.J. Brannen’s store, now a local watering hole, and across the street the original railroad depot. He’d know the whistles and watch the trains rumble by each day. And he’d smile and tip his hat to the passengers in a horse-drawn Studebaker wagon, clip-clopping down the street on a peaceful Sunday afternoon.

Text by Rose Houk

From the beginning, Flagstaff was a multicultural brew of Chinese, Hispanics, Anglos, Native Americans, African-Americans, Basques, and others. That diversity of humanity remains very much a part of the town’s character. Standing on the corner of Aspen and San Francisco streets, this is what I’m likely to see: in summer window-shopping tourists stroll along the streets, cameras draped around their necks. In winter skiers swoosh by in Technicolor nylon. French and German visitors, just off the train, sip cappuccinos at one of the town’s many coffee bars. Two river runners bound by in requisite sandals and shorts. A cowboy, legs bowed, stows groceries in the back of a pickup. A Navajo grandmother in a tiered full skirt and velvet blouse crosses the street. There’s a student in jeans and flannel shirt, a Rastafarian with long coiled curls, a punker with brightly spiked hair, and a professional dressed for the office.

CELEBRATES TODAY

Though always the financial and legal hub of Flagstaff, in the 1960s and '70s downtown was suffering the fate of many city centers throughout the United States. Department stores had moved to the mall, nightlife was scarce, and the streets and sidewalks showed signs of neglect.

But Flagstaff hasn't lost its heart or its history. Facades fashionable in the 1930s and '50s are being peeled off to reveal the warm red brick and sandstone block, locally made and quarried, used for building in the 1880s and '90s. Downtown is now the chosen location of a steady stream of parades and festivals through the year. And property owners and the city, with the Main Street Foundation, are planning a revamping of downtown that they hope will make it an even more vital place.

From my office in the Babbitt Building, I can go across the street to the Weatherford Hotel, comforted in the thought that Zane Grey holed up there to write Call of the Canyon. I like the small-town atmosphere that still pervades downtown. If I need to see someone, I don't have to make an appointment. A visit to the post office in the morning or to the corner newsstand in the afternoon nearly always ensures that I'll run into that person. The postman delivers my mail, even if it's addressed incorrectly. The friendly meter maid smiles while she writes me a parking ticket.

This year's centennial is not Flagstaff's first. It already observed one in 1976, marking what some consider the real beginnings of the town: the presence of the first permanent settler, Thomas Forsythe McMillan, and the raising of the American flag on a tall ponderosa pine by a group of Boston colonizers. That event is now legend as the source of the town's name.

By 1880 the Atlantic & Pacific Railroad was steaming westward across Arizona Territory, toward what would become the town of Flagstaff. At a place called Old Town Spring, where water flowed freely, surveyors, tie cutters, and track layers made a temporary home, and several saloons and breweries set up shop to sustain them.

In August, 1882, the tracks arrived in Flagstaff. Seeking flatter terrain, the railroad soon forsook Old Town and decided to build a proper depot about a half mile back to the east. Old Town merchant P.J. Brannen and others moved along with it to what became known as New Town. They built their businesses just across the street from the depot on the main drag, then called Railroad Avenue or Front Street (now Santa Fe Avenue or Route 66). And Chicago businessman Edward Ayer had opened his sawmill to furnish the hundreds of thousands of ties the A&P demanded. The whistle that sounded from Milltown each morning, noon, and evening meant jobs for about 200 people.

yesterdays

In those days, Flagstaff was the archetypal wild frontier town. Barroom brawls, shootings, and robberies were commonplace, and prisoners were secured from the lynch mobs in the calaboose (made of railroad ties) on North Leroux. A red-light district was part of the landscape, and "decent" ladies would not be seen walking down saloon-lined Railroad Avenue.

But as the A&P construction crews moved on down the line, the little burg of Flagstaff started to settle down. Churches, a school, and other trappings of permanence and respectability were established. In 1888 two brothers from Cincinnati, David and William Babbitt, had completed their large sandstone mercantile store at the corner of West Aspen and North San Francisco. During those years, fires repeatedly destroyed several businesses, but they were nearly always rebuilt, of lasting brick or stone, in short order.

Historian, author, and Flagstaff native Richard Mangum said that “just as soon as Flagstaff got enough people to howl, they started howling” for their own county. In 1891 they succeeded: Coconino County was carved from Yavapai County, with Flagstaff as the county seat.

In 1893 the weekly Coconino Sun reported a sort of building boom. Local merchants were improving their stores with plate-glass fronts and putting additions onto their buildings, and houses were being built. The following year the county courthouse was going up, as was the lovely turreted building at the Reform School on the south side (now known as Old Main on the campus of Northern Arizona University). In addition Bostonian Percival Lowell was building his new astronomical observatory above town on what would be called Mars Hill.

With all this activity and development, the men and women of Flagstaff inevitably started to feel that the town should have its own government. One hundred and sixty taxpayers petitioned the Coconino County Board of Supervisors, spelling out the boundaries of the town and requesting incorporation. The supervisors agreed, and on May 26, 1894, the town of Flagstaff was officially incorporated.

Boston colonist Gorham Bray, sheepman J.F. Daggs, saloon owner J.A. Vail, P.J. Brannen, and David Babbitt were appointed the first city councilmen. A month later they met and chose Bray as the first mayor — and passed some ordinances and levied some taxes. Saloons, billiard and faro games, minstrel performances, traveling circuses, and peddlers and vendors were among those that faced taxation (and, as George Hochderffer discovered when he went to collect, not all of those affected were in favor). Another new ordinance which prohibited horses, cattle, sheep, goats, and geese from running at large within town limits also was not well accepted.

Bray's term as mayor was short, and by April of the next year David Babbitt had the job. Babbitt outlined problems facing the new town of about 2,000 people, problems that many in Flagstaff, and other towns for that matter, will find surprisingly familiar.

The question of revenue was "perplexing," but license and property taxes were coming in. Although some street improvements had been undertaken, still "our highways are in a very unsatisfactory condition." Babbitt regretfully observed that "the streets are daily treated to an unsavory and unsightly top-dressing of refuse." A police court had been established, and, of utmost importance, a fire department was being organized. "That Ditch," the Rio de Flag which courses through town, was enlarged to help relieve the annual spring flooding problem. And Old Town Spring, at that time Flagstaff's only available water supply, was to be cleaned, enclosed, and "put in good condition for the coming season."

In an upbeat assessment of the condition of the newly incorporated town, Mayor Babbitt said that "the general average of health has been excellent; the moral tone of the community has perceptibly improved; no instances of abject poverty have come to the notice of the Council. On the contrary, all appear to be enjoying a moderate degree of prosperity."

From its railroad, logging, and livestock origins, Flagstaff has grown and changed over the last century into a city now approaching 50,000 in population, with an economy based on the university, government, and tourism. But there's one thing George Hochderffer would still recognize: the hue and cry that rises periodically against those scofflaws who insist upon bicycling on the narrow walks of downtown.

Author's Note: An 18-member citizen committee and city special events coordinator Kris Swanson have organized a number of events throughout the year to observe the 1994 Flagstaff Centennial. May 22 through 30, Centennial Week, will feature an arts and crafts historical fair, games, and contests. One contest is for the menfolk, to see who can grow the bushiest beard in the shortest amount of time. For more information, telephone (602) 779-7627 or 779-7611.

Rose Houk also wrote about Beale Springs in this issue and about Polacca Indian Day, for which Michael Collier also contributed the photographs.