Lowell Observatory: A Flagstaff Paragon
A Pantheon TO THE PIONEERS OF ASTRONOMY
By Carle Hodge
Quick quiz: who first spied the planet Pluto? Clyde W. Tombaugh, as you probably know. And who was Percival Lowell? Easy: the Boston Brahmin at whose Flagstaff observatory Tombaugh cast his name into the annals of astronomy.
But Vesto Melvin Slipher?
His scientific heirs credit him with a triumph far more seminal, to them, than the discovery of a planet. At Lowell Observatory in the early 1900s, "V.M." harvested the first hints of an ever-spreading universe, swirling out endlessly into eternity.
An almost palpable aura bequeathed by the facility's pantheon of pioneering titans still pervades the low piney mesa that Andrew Ellicott Douglass discovered for its founder a century ago.
Their artifacts are displayed for all to see, among them the spectrograph Slipher used to collect evidence that we inhabit an expanding cosmos. One also can examine Percival Lowell's sketches of Mars — astronomy had not yet adapted to photography — as well as the device with which Tombaugh located the ninth planet.
Lowell himself remains, literally, atop what he named Mars Hill. He rests in a mausoleum fashioned from the gray granite of his native New England, roofed with a glass bubble reminiscent of observatory domes.
At 100 years, the world's largest private, nonprofit observatory continues to break the bounds of human knowledge. It is scheduled to dedicate a new visitors center May 28. Precisely 10 decades earlier, the proper Bostonian stepped from an Atlantic & Pacific Railroad train for his initial look at what Douglass described in a telegram as "a clearing in the forest."
This still was the untamed Territory of Arizona and Flagstaff a frontier lumber and livestock village of fewer than 900 souls. Douglass promised that the hamlet was not without amenities, however. Those included a hotel sufficiently civilized that "ladies can stay."
At the time, the aristocratic Lowells were, owing to the worth of their textile mills, a family of immodest means. A poem of the period contended that "in the land of the bean and the cod/ the Lowells speak only to the Cabots/ and the Cabots speak only to God."
Although anything astral stirred Lowell, Mars proved to be his obsession. One reason: he thought he discerned on the ruddy planet canals constructed by an intelligence perhaps surpassing our own. That idea stoked imaginations worldwide. And Lowell, without formal training in the field, became famous among people who otherwise cared little about any world beyond their own.
Early in 1894, then, he hired Douglass, a young Harvard astronomer, lent him a six-inch telescope, and dispatched him to the Southwest to scout out the best possible location for observing. Hurry, Douglass was ordered. Within months, Mars would swing unusually close to Earth, and Lowell wanted to be prepared.
Douglass tested settings in or around Tombstone, Tucson (where the mosquitoes incensed him), Phoenix, Prescott (his first favorite), and Ash Fork before reaching Flagstaff and what he called Site 11, it being the 11th he inspected. "Height important," Lowell wired. That certainly portrayed Site 11, perched west of and 330 feet above downtown Flagstaff, itself about 6,900 feet above sea level.
Local businessmen offered to buy the land for the observatory and incise a wagon road up the mesa. Whatever weight that offer held, Lowell settled on Flagstaff. Its town snubbed, The Tucson Daily Star suspected in print some sort of plot by "Boston capitalists."
That summer permitted postcard-perfect seeing. But the scientists had not considered the northern Arizona winter. By January fierce gales ricocheting off the San Francisco Peaks distorted the astronomers' eye view of the nocturnal sky. Snow piled so deep Douglass had to use a ladder to enter the dome through a slit in the roof.
By April he and Lowell conceded their error. They closed the observatory, and Lowell sent his minions scurrying to try dry, remote environs in the Andes of South America, New Mexico, and the Sahara Desert in North Africa. Still he decided at last that Flagstaff "averages better than any place I know." Eleven months later, he and Douglass returned to the clearing in the Arizona forest.
And the following year, 1896, brought a large sophisticated telescope, a $20,000 24-inch refractor perfected by the famous firm of Alvan Clark & Sons in Cambridge, Massachusetts.
...graph... ...ally reveals... ...t. The darkening... ...and May to mid-June y... ...remains practically sta... ...development takes p... ...able regularity. I... ...cap and other... ...on the looko... ...any anomal... ...dark regions... ...higher latit... ...The r... ...and then... ...dark ar...
Now a National Historic Landmark and still resident in its original dome of ponderosa planks, “The Clark” remains a Mars Hill workhorse. In the 1960s, the 30-ton telescope provided data for mapping the moon and gave the astronauts a preliminary glimpse of their lunar destination.
Lowell and Douglass harnessed the 24-inch in their stubborn search for the illusive Martian channels. Or they did, together, until 1901. That year Douglass complained to a Lowell relative of Percival’s “unscientific methods.” The relative told Lowell, who dismissed Douglass forthwith.
Douglass went to Tucson as the first director of the University of Arizona’s Steward Observatory. While there he concentrated on attempts to correlate sun spots with variations in the annual growth rings in trees. He failed. But he did invent the science of dendrochronology, which would enable scientists to date the wood in prehistoric ruins, chart climatic changes over past centuries, and determine when earthquakes and forest fires took place.
Not long after Douglass departed, Lowell, saying “I shall not want another permanent assistant,” rather reluctantly hired V.M. Slipher. A quiet, deliberative chap who had been a country schoolteacher in Indiana, Slipher came on a “temporary” basis that would last 53 years. One of his early duties: the care of the observatory cow and her calf, Venus and Satellite.
He first needed to bond with a spectrograph Lowell bought a few months earlier. Eventually spectrographs would revolutionize astronomy. At the genesis of the 20th century, few observatories owned one.
Such instruments work in much the way that water droplets in the air create rainbows. Spectrographs shred light into spectra — bands of color or so-called spectral lines arranged by wavelength — that represent the emission or absorption of light by specific atoms or molecules. A spectrogram of a star reveals such things as the star’s velocity of approach or recession, its temperature, and composition.
At Lowell’s suggestion, Slipher attached the spectrograph to the Clark telescope in 1912 and began to peer among the dim but ubiquitous luminous patches then known as white nebulae. A reigning riddle was the nature of those objects. Were they simply clouds of gas within our Milky Way, as most contended? Or were they assemblages of stars outside our own galaxy?
Scientists already knew that the spectral lines of a light source rushing toward an observer increasingly shift toward the blue (or the shorter wavelength) end of the spectrum. Conversely a retreating source shifts toward the red end of the spectrum. In the constellation Virgo, The Maiden, Slipher found a spiral nebula hurtling away from Earth at a previously unthinkable velocity: 2 million miles an hour.
In 1914 he reported to the American Astronomical Society his recording of 15 such objects, “the striking preponderance [of them] fleeing” away from us. Lowell Observatory at once became, astronomically, the little engine that could.
Slipher pushed the 24-inch to its very limits. A few years later, in California, another explorer began building upon the Arizona findings. Edwin Hubble, with a new 100-inch reflector on Mount Wilson near Pasadena, established that everything in creation races away from everything else. And the white nebulae were in fact alien galaxies.
Two years following the Slipher bombshell, in 1916, Lowell died unexpectedly of a stroke. He was 61. Because there was no other place for it at the observatory, his casket was eased beneath a pine tree and covered with pine boughs. It was left there seven years — until a mausoleum met his wife’s approval and finally reached completion.
Childless, Lowell endowed the observatory with funds he hoped would last indefinitely. He also named a cousin, architect Guy Lowell, the center’s sole trustee. He and subsequent trustees would choose their successors within the family.
The widow Lowell, Constance, challenged Percival’s will, demanding greater control of his estate. Although she ultimately lost, the case languished in court for nearly a decade while the observatory drifted with virtually no income.
Despite increased skepticism among his peers, Lowell took with him to the tomb his conviction that canals spiderweb across the Martian surface. But he had started another search. Researchers had noted an odd wobble in the orbit of Neptune. Concluding that the gravitational tug of a neighboring but still unseen planet must be responsible, Lowell plotted where what he referred to as Planet X should lurk. He and others at the observatory sought in vain to home in on it.
WHEN YOU GO
To reach Lowell Observatory in Flagstaff, head west on Santa Fe Avenue (Old Route 66). That street jogs to the left and becomes Mars Hill Road, which winds up to the visitors center.
Because of the danger of forest fires, smoking is not permitted on Mars Hill.
The observatory is open 9 A.M. to 5 P.M. Monday through Saturday; from noon until 5 P.M. Sundays. There is a modest admission fee. To inquire about lectures, telescope viewing, and events, call (602) 774-3358 and ask for the public-programs office.
Once the will was settled, the quest for Planet X resumed, aided by a 13-inch telescope contributed by Lowell’s brother, Harvard President A. Lawrence Lowell. Slipher decided the hunt needed another pair of eyes.
He chose a Kansas farm boy, an amateur astronomer, who drew various planets sighted with a telescope of his own making. Clyde Tombaugh detrained in Flagstaff late in 1929, shortly before the cataclysmic Wall Street crash. He slept in an upstairs room at the observatory.
His assignment, first, was to capture suspect segments of the sky on 14-by-17-inch glass photographic plates shot with the 13-inch reflector. Next, pairs of pictures of a specific area photographed at different times were analyzed with a blink comparator, a machine fitted with a microscope that permitted a user to rapidly switch back and forth between the two views. If something moved between the two exposures, it might be a planet.
This may seem straightforward. But each plate brimmed with perhaps millions of shiny pinpoints. Moreover, the far-off Planet X turned out to be the runt of the planetary litter, little more than two-tenths of one percent of the mass of Earth. Finding a dime in a dumpster might have been easier.
Finally, on an overcast February afternoon in 1930, six months after he started and exactly two weeks past his 24th birthday, Tombaugh detected telltale blips on plates he had photographed the previous month. “This is it,” he exclaimed to himself. It was. But because clouds precluded using a telescope to confirm his finding, he walked downtown to watch Gary Cooper in The Virginian. He later admitted he could remember little about the picture’s plot.
Slipher, to be certain a new planet had been spotted, ordered a thorough series of checks. Thus the world did not learn of the feat until March 13, the day Lowell would have been 75.
Immediately an international brouhaha arose over what the object should be called. Mrs. Lowell insisted on “Lowell” or (she said her friends urged this) “Constance.” But Slipher hewed to the Greek and Roman deities nomenclature of the other planets. On May 1, he picked the name Pluto, after the Greek god of the underworld, an appellation suggested to him by an 11-year-old British schoolgirl.
Tombaugh stayed on at the observatory another 13 years with some time off to complete his degree. During the 1944-’45 academic year, he taught at UCLA. When he returned to the observatory, Slipher informed him that funds were tight and that he should seek employment elsewhere.
The only American to discover a planet — indeed the only person since J.C. Galle came upon Neptune in 1846 — found himself jobless. But that did not last long. He soon headed a team tracking rockets at the White Sands Proving Grounds in New Mexico, and he eventually joined the faculty at New Mexico State University in Las Cruces.
Tombaugh often visits the spawning ground of his career. He returned in 1989 to inaugurate the Pluto Walk, a 350-foot paved path along which people can stride — symbolically at least — across the solar system.
Signs along the way make up a scale model, the 350 feet representing the 3.6 billion miles from the sun to Pluto. Markers for the nine planets indicate each body’s size and distance from the sun. And at the end of the walk stands the 13-inch Pluto telescope in its old stone home, built of dark native basalt.
The observatory always has welcomed the citizenry, some 50,000 of whom showed up last year. Lowell himself loved playing host. When Tombaugh first came, he guided guests — along with stoking the basement furnace. Illinois-born Robert Lowell Millis, 52, the current director, helped with visitors as a graduate student during his first summer (1965) on the mesa. (His middle name is a coincidence.)
Telescope viewing, hands-on classes for both children and adults, lectures and the like have long been regular fare. During the past few years, however, the staff has exerted special efforts to make the institution more public-friendly. The present trustee (the fourth), William Lowell Putnam, 69, Lowell’s grandnephew and the owner of a Springfield, Massachusetts, travel agency, assigns hospitality high priority.
The Pluto Walk became one answer. Another: the new visitors center, which includes an auditorium, gift shop, direly needed public rest rooms, and exhibits that explain what astronomers do. Video segments show them at work and at play. In one, Jon Holtzman, a Lowell cosmologist, plucks a banjo in a bluegrass band.
“We want people to know,” Millis says, “that this is not just a historic site but a busy modern observatory.” Busy and modern it is. With an annual budget of $2.4 million — a third of it from the Lowell endowment, the rest from contracts and gifts — 16 astronomers and some 30 technicians and other support personnel track a tantalizing mix of inquiries. Among them: comets, star births, solar variation, the atmosphere of planets, and the distribution of asteroids.
Whatever they do, the Lowell scientists seldom stray far from their founder’s admonition, carved into his tomb. “To see into the beyond requires purity,” he said in part. “Only in places raised above and aloof from men can [the astronomer] profitably pursue his search.”
Already a member? Login ».