Lodging

The couple had taken a break from their obligations in California in the midst of the challenges the COVID-19 pandemic had thrown at them. They visited Prescott and Jerome, then made an unplanned stop in Sedona for a couple of nights. And something beckoned them to put down roots after a stay at an old motel on Jordan Road.

“​​We stayed in Room 7, which we now call ‘lucky Room 7,’ and when we checked out, we stopped through a real estate agency in town, just to see what was going on” and if any small hotels were on the market, Feldman says.

“We were attracted to the specific building [because] it had great bones for the making of a one-of-a-kind boutique hotel,” says Mike Weiss, co-founder and co-CEO of Trailborn and Castle Peak Holdings. “We worked with Lake Flato to fully reimagine the property and bring our vision to life by restoring elements such as the monument sign, Camp Hall — our event space — and Miss Kitty’s restaurant, while also decorating the spaces with curated art, vintage finds and playful décor.”

The property dates to March 1925, when it was homesteaded. In the century since, it’s had many uses, including a short time as a bed and breakfast in the 1980s. “We understood that the property, the location and the town were special, and we needed to share that,” Janet says. “So the bed and breakfast was born.”

The Caylors bought the mansion during the COVID-19 pandemic after they noticed it was for sale; as it turned out, Rob knew the previous owner through his building company. He and Margo decided to operate it as an inn, with a heavy emphasis on historic preservation. “We had a previous innkeeper who would say, ‘You’ve just walked into a time machine; you’ve stepped back hundreds of years,’ ” Margo says.

The property, on Brewery Avenue in Brewery Gulch, features two rentable units. The Nopales Suite (pictured) is a one-bedroom, one-bathroom apartment with a kitchenette and is suitable for two guests. The larger Agave Casita is well suited for two, as well. And, along with its one bedroom and one bathroom, it features a full kitchen loaded with all the comforts of home. Both units are available through Airbnb. 

The tribe answered, and the hotel, which is the first Hopi lodging venture constructed off tribal land, features design elements that mimic traditional Hopi architecture: beams with wooden slats; a whitewashed look to the walls, to reflect the tribe’s seasonal cleansing rituals; and an extensive collection of original artwork, including a Duane Koyawena mural behind the reception desk. 

“There are lots of ghost stories,” says Amy Naico, who bought the hotel with her husband, Kenny, in 2023. “Our motto is that we’re your ‘haunt away from home.’ ”

The Oliver House opened in 1909, in the aftermath of a fire that burned much of Bisbee. “Perhaps the finest building on the hill is the recently completed private hotel of Mrs. Frank Oliver,” the Bisbee Daily Review reported that year.

 An astronaut mannequin, stationed at the hotel’s entrance, is the first hint of the history — and kitsch — found at every turn. According to the hotel’s general manager, Zach Miller, the mannequin references the astronauts who trained in the Flagstaff area before walking on the moon. Meanwhile, the star-patterned pillows strewn about the orange midcentury couches in the board-game-furnished lobby allude to Flagstaff’s Lowell Observatory, where Pluto was discovered in 1930.

Since it opened in 2020, Origins has revolved around making guests comfortable, employing lessons the couple learned on business trips during their corporate careers. As Saelens recalls, she reached a point of saying, “We just can’t do this until we retire; this is really hard on our brains.” When she approached Raible about opening a B&B, he was on board: “I liked it because it would be a great excuse to build a really cool house.”

But a fire in May 2012 destroyed the building next door and caused smoke damage to the hotel, resulting in yet another iteration. Today, the Grand Highland Hotel offers 12 guest rooms, each with its own bathroom and upgraded amenities. The hotel’s general manager, Natasha Baierl, says the owners prioritized keeping some pieces of the original building, and that’s what makes the hotel a part of Prescott history.